PDA

View Full Version : Would love to see side by side Dragon skin vs MX Epic skin



Robert Ruffo New
11-27-2014, 10:29 AM
I think I am not alone in not being entirely sure what the differences are in skin rendition between the two systems. I mean I THINK I know, but...

Did Dragon solve the Freckles Issue MX had?

What other differences are there?

I like to learn in a technical way "Film like" and other abstract and purely subjective pronunciations I find less useful. To me abstract feelings-based opinions are very suitable to commenting on finished work, but not on camera systems.

Anyway, just looking for info to help us decide on Dec 1st deadline.

Ulf Krentz
11-27-2014, 10:56 AM
Robert,

Honestly - go for it. Skin Tones and highlight rolloff are exactly what we´ve been waiting for. While a liked the MX for an edgy dark / mysterious look I found it quite a challenge to get beauty shots from it. The dragon is better straight out of the cam than I was sometimes able to achieve before. You got to give the Dragon light, rate it like 400 or so.
Now you´re quite late to the party, I would have advised to rent it and test it for yourself which might be too late now. But you still have the option to sell your MX and get a new brain after Dec 1st…
This was our first dragon shot: https://vimeo.com/106123939

Cheers,

Ulf

Mike P.
11-27-2014, 11:32 AM
I'd be interested in seeing this as well... Specifically the same shot, at the same settings -- e.g. both Cameras rated at and lit for ISO250/RG4.

I've found that MX skin tones always look substantially better when they're dropped down by a stop in post (which correlates to the darker looks of Fincher and Soderbergh).

sam karr
11-27-2014, 11:53 AM
There was this post from Werner Jauch a while back:

"I shot some more comparison files of Scarlet Dragon versus Scarlet MX today
File A003_C003 is Scarlet Dragon 5k
File A003_C004 is Scarlet Dragon 4k
File A002_C001 is Scarlet MX

I wanted to see skin indoor tungsten in this comparison.
In each case camera location was in the same spot, I stood in as near as I could the same place, lighting was one tungsten light, camera right, Canon 50mm lens f2.8.
(focus looks a little off in one of the shots, but then I was operating the camera via the Redmote)

Dropbox link here:
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/he053vyv3...RpObJxFEa?dl=0 (https://www.dropbox.com/sh/he053vyv3gr9xr1/AAD-fkPqaJ0Yid3nRpObJxFEa?dl=0) "

By just doing a simple white balance on the shirt and pushing a bit the saturation, I clearly see a much more monochromatic magenta skin on MX and more tonalities on dragon.

Alex Vo
11-28-2014, 07:27 PM
I thought this was a really helpful test comparing the Epic, Dragon and Alexa. Some funky things going on with exposure on the Alexa but I found this pretty helpful.

https://vimeo.com/101107159