Short Film: "Pull Back" Shot on Scarlet

[Benoît-Joan Clariana-Roig]

I can't see any noise... but maybe I'm a fanboy...:)

It's pretty obvious, even on Vimeo.

[Carmine Scalzi]

Yes but we all can see compression noise different to the footage noise, I think..

It's pretty obvious, even on Vimeo.

[Ryan Koo]

The 5D is a great camera for the money.

That said, we chose ONE shot from the 5D to use -- the one that intercut well and didn't look too soft or exhibit aliasing. Just because you find a use for a 5D in special situations (in this case co-director Raafi climbed up onto some girders on which we weren't comfortable perching a RED) does not mean it could replace the RED for EVERY shot. Lots of big-budget features intercut DSLR shots without you noticing, but if they'd shot the whole thing on a DSLR you'd definitely notice.

[Timothy Carr]

The 5D is a great camera for the money.

That said, we chose ONE shot from the 5D to use -- the one that intercut well and didn't look too soft or exhibit aliasing. Just because you find a use for a 5D in special situations (in this case co-director Raafi climbed up onto some girders on which we weren't comfortable perching a RED) does not mean it could replace the RED for EVERY shot. Lots of big-budget features intercut DSLR shots without you noticing, but if they'd shot the whole thing on a DSLR you'd definitely notice.

Exactly. Nuff said everyone, now shut up about the DSLR vs Red! PLEASE!