Steve I find it curious that you attack Reduser members but praise Jim Jannard when it was Jim that posted the most absurd attack on your film of anyone:
Your film though proclaims to do one thing while doing another. If the goal was to see how different DPs light a scene then why did you include dumb 'rules' to make it into some sort of game-show challenge? Give the DPs a blank canvas and a repeatable scene if that's your goal. By forcing the DPs to keep certain lights in the scene we aren't seeing a "Creative" test, we're just seeing a badly administered empirical test--but with a cop-out excuse that it's not the real 'test'. It's close enough to being a test that it's camera test. But it's divergent enough that its results are meaningless.This "test" was a crime... as expected.
Mostly I'm disappointed though that you've sunk to the same level of whininess as those you accuse of being whiners.