This idea of a real test has gotten out of control apparently.
Several companies have refused to participate. I guess if I were them I might consider the same thing.
Resolution is not everything. But it is something.
Dynamic range matters. So does the "feel" of the image.
Frame rates matter.
We are going to take down our offer to do a comparison test at RSH. The grief and complication doesn't warrant the effort.
I hope that everyone can do some testing on their own that includes all aspects of image capture. We just aren't up for the grief. We have better things to do.
There are lots of options for you to consider. I hope that RED is one of them.